Old Spice vs. 360Feel: A Natural Soap Throwdown

Let’s be honest—Old Spice has been a staple in guys’ bathrooms for decades. It’s bold, it’s branded, and it’s everywhere.

But if you’re starting to care about what actually goes into your grooming products, it’s worth asking:
How does Old Spice compare to a clean, handcrafted alternative like 360Feel?

In this natural soap throwdown, we’re breaking down both brands across five key categories—so you can decide what belongs in your shower.

🧴 1. Ingredients: What’s Inside the Bar?

Old Spice:

• Uses sodium laureth sulfate (SLES) and other synthetic surfactants
• Includes fragrance/parfum (a catch-all term that can include dozens of undisclosed chemicals)
• Often contains preservatives, artificial dyes, and alcohols

360Feel:

• Made with plant-based oils like coconut, olive, and castor
• Scented with pure essential oils (no artificial fragrance)
• Includes natural exfoliants like oatmeal, charcoal, and clay
• Retains glycerin for skin moisture

✅ Winner: 360Feel’s Natural Soap Bars

💧 2. Skin Benefits

Old Spice:

• Can leave skin dry or irritated due to synthetic detergents
• Scent may be overwhelming or cause sensitivity

360Feel:

• Gentle on all skin types—even sensitive skin
• Helps maintain skin’s natural barrier with moisturizing oils and no parabens

✅ Recommended for: Guys with dry patches, body acne, or sensitive skin
Try:
🪵 Pine Tar Soap
🌿 Oatmeal Milk & Honey

🌿 3. Scent Profiles

Old Spice:

• Known for bold, cologne-like scents (e.g., Swagger, Bearglove)
• Fragrance is synthetic, often overpowering

360Feel:

• Scented with real botanicals like Bay Rum, Patchouli, and Citrus
• Clean, masculine, and subtle—built to last without overpowering

✅ Want something more natural and skin-safe?
Try:
🔥 Bay Rum
🌲 Island Citrus

♻️ 4. Packaging & Sustainability

Old Spice:

• Packaged in plastic
• Mass-produced with minimal transparency around sourcing

360Feel:

• Packaged in recyclable paper
• Handcrafted in small batches in the USA
• Made using sustainable and biodegradable ingredients

✅ Winner for eco-conscious grooming: 360Feel

💸 5. Price & Value

Old Spice:

• ~$5–6 per bar
• Heavily marketed, low ingredient cost

360Feel:

• ~$7–8 per handcrafted bar
• Premium natural ingredients, no fillers, lasts longer
• More value per use when stored correctly

💡 Pro Tip: Buy the 4-bar 360Feel gift set on Amazon for variety and savings.

🏁 The Final Verdict

Category	Old Spice	360Feel
Ingredients	❌	✅
Skin Benefits	❌	✅
Natural Scents	❌	✅
Eco-Friendly	❌	✅
Long-Term Value	⚠️	✅

If you’re into bold branding and nostalgia, Old Spice delivers—but if you want a cleaner, safer, and more skin-friendly bar that smells like confidence, 360Feel is the clear winner.